(Download) "Plaut v. Munford." by United States Court Of Appeals Second Circuit * eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: Plaut v. Munford.
- Author : United States Court Of Appeals Second Circuit
- Release Date : January 23, 1951
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 51 KB
Description
In 1938 the plaintiff sold 15,700 shares of common stock of Lehn & Fink Products Corp. for $138,836.50. These shares represented, after stock split-ups and dividends, 600 shares of Lehn & Fink that he had inherited by specific bequest under the will of his father who had died on June 17, 1915. In his income tax return for 1938, when computing his capital gain on the sale of the 15,700 shares, the plaintiff reported $247.75 as the fair market value in 1915 of each of the 600 shares which he had inherited. This was the value fixed by the Surrogate of New York County in determining the New York transfer tax as of the date of the fathers death. In 1941, the plaintiff filed a claim for a refund alleging that the fair value of the Lehn & Fink stock in 1915 had been $5,142.85 per share, thereby eliminating the gain realized on the sale and any tax therefor. The claim was disallowed by the Commissioner and this action followed in the District Court. After trial and argument, Hincks, J., adopted the Surrogates valuation formula and upon correcting certain errors in his computations which are not challenged here, found the shares in question to be worth $610.36 apiece and gave judgment for $3,386.95, the amount of the resulting overpayment of tax, plus interest. The plaintiff appeals, asserting that the proper value was at least $3,150 per share.
 "Plaut v. Munford." by United States Court Of Appeals Second Circuit * eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free){kind=link}